Filed by FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP, INC. Pursuant to Rule 425 under the Securities Act of 1933 and deemed filed pursuant to Rule 14a-12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Subject Company: FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP, INC. (Commission File No. 1-12305) The following is from an investor presentation that took place on October 7, 2003 in connection with the proposed acquisition by Webster Financial Corporation of FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP, INC.: [WEBSTER FINANCIAL [FIRSTFED LOGO] CORPORATION LOGO] FIRST FED AMERICA BANCORP, INC. We Find a Way A POWERFUL FORCE IN SOUTHERN NEW ENGLAND OCTOBER 7, 2003 Forward Looking Statements This presentation contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These forward-looking statements include, but are not limited to, statements about (i) the benefits of the merger between Webster Financial Corporation ("Webster" or "WBS") and FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP, INC. ("FIRSTFED" or "FAB"), including future financial and operating results, cost savings and accretion to reported earnings that may be realized from the merger; (ii) Webster's and FIRSTFED's plans, objectives, expectations and intentions and other statements contained in this presentation that are not historical facts; and (iii) other statements identified by words such as "expects," "anticipates, ""intends," "plans," "believes," "seeks," "estimates" or words of similar meaning. These forward-looking statements are based upon the current beliefs and expectations of Webster's and FIRSTFED's management and are inherently subject to significant business, economic and competitive uncertainties and contingencies, many of which are beyond our control. In addition, these forward-looking statements are subject to assumptions with respect to future business strategies and decisions that are subject to change. Actual results may differ materially from the anticipated results discussed in these forward-looking statements. The following factors, among others, could cause actual results to differ materially from the anticipated results or other expectations expressed in the forward-looking statements: (1) the businesses of Webster and FIRSTFED may not be combined successfully, or such combination may take longer to accomplish than expected; (2) the cost savings from the merger may not be fully realized or may take longer to realize than expected; (3) operating costs, customer loss and business disruption following the merger, including adverse effects on relationships with employees, may be greater than expected; (4) governmental approvals of the merger may not be obtained, or adverse regulatory conditions may be imposed in connection with governmental approvals of the merger; (5) the stockholders of FIRSTFED may fail to approve the merger; (6) adverse governmental or regulatory policies may be enacted; (7) the interest rate environment may further compress margins and adversely affect net interest income; (8) the risks associated with continued diversification of assets and adverse changes to credit quality; (9) the risks associated with a proposed balance sheet deleveraging; (10) difficulties associated with achieving expected future financial results; (11) competition from other financial services companies in Webster's and FIRSTFED's markets; (12) the risk of an economic slowdown that would adversely affect credit quality and loan originations. Additional factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those expressed in the forward-looking statements are discussed in Webster's and FIRSTFED's reports (such as Annual Reports on Form 10-K, Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q and Current Reports on Form 8-K) filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission and available at the SEC's Internet site (http://lwww,sec.gov). All subsequent written and oral forward looking statements concerning the proposed transaction or other matters attributable to Webster or FIRSTFED or any person acting on their behalf are expressly qualified in their entirety by the cautionary statements above. Except as required by law, Webster and FIRSTFED do not undertake any obligation to update any forward-looking statement to reflect circumstances or events that occur after the date the forward-looking statement is made. 2 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Additional Information The proposed transaction will be submitted to FIRSTFED's stockholders for their consideration. Webster and FIRSTFED will file with the SEC a registration statement, a proxy statement/prospectus and other relevant documents concerning the proposed transaction with the SEC. Stockholders of FIRSTFED are urged to read the registration statement and the proxy statement/prospectus when it becomes available and any other relevant documents filed with the SEC, as well as any amendments or supplements to those documents, because they will contain important information. You will be able to obtain a free copy of the proxy statement/prospectus, as well as other filings containing information about Webster and FIRSTFED, at the SEC's Internet site (http://www.sec.gov). Copies of the proxy statement/prospectus and the SEC filings that will be incorporated by reference in the proxy statement/prospectus can be obtained, without charge, by directing a request to Terrence K. Mangan, Senior Vice President/Investor Relations, Webster Financial Corporation, Webster Plaza, Waterbury, CT 06702 (203) 578-2318 or to Edward A. Hjerpe, Chief Operating Officer and Chief Financial Officer, FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP, INC., ONE FIRSTFED PARK, Swansea, MA 02777 (508) 679-8181. FIRSTFED and its directors and executive officers may be deemed to be participants in the solicitation of proxies from the stockholders of FIRSTFED in connection with the merger. Information about the directors and executive officers of FIRSTFED and their ownership of FIRSTFED common stock is set forth in the proxy statement, dated June 26, 2003, for FIRSTFED's 2003 annual meeting of stockholders, as filed with the SEC on a Schedule 14A. Additional information regarding the interests of such participants may be obtained by reading the proxy statement/prospectus when it becomes available. 3 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] A Powerful Force in Southern New England The combination of Webster and FIRSTFED creates: - 46th largest bank in the United States with $16 billion in assets (1) - $2.2 billion in market capitalization (2) - 141-branch retail footprint in Connecticut, Massachusetts and Rhode Island - Full retail and commercial banking product offering 1. Pro forma at June 30, 2003, adjusted for planned balance sheet deleveraging. 2. Market data as of October 3, 2003. 4 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Summary of Significant Terms Value per FIRSTFED Share: $24.50 per share Transaction Value: $456.5 million (1) Consideration: 60% stock / 40% cash Exchange Ratio: Fixed at 0.5954 Webster shares for each FIRSTFED share (2) Transaction Structure: Tax-free exchange with election mechanism Estimated Cost Savings: Approximately 25% of FIRSTFED's expenses Merger-Related Costs: Capitalized after-tax restructuring charge of $30.6 million and one-time after-tax merger related expenses of $3.1 million Balance Sheet Deleveraging: Up to $1.5 billion through a combination of investment portfolio reduction and/or loan sales/securitization Revenue Enhancement: $9.5 million identified, none assumed 1. Includes cash out of options and net of Webster's holding of 328,800 shares of FIRSTFED. 2. Based on WBS closing share price of $41.15 on October 3, 2003. 5 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Summary of Significant Terms Due Diligence: Completed Management Representation: Robert Stoico, Chairman and CEO of MA and RI Region Ed Hjerpe, President and COO of MA and RI Region Board Representation: Robert Stoico to be added to Webster Financial Corporation and Webster Bank Boards Walk-Away: Limited price-based walkaway, subject to top-up right (1) Termination Fee: $17 million Required Approvals: FIRSTFED shareholders Customary regulatory approvals Expected Closing: First quarter of 2004 1. FIRSTFED has the right of termination if the value of Webster stock declines by 20% and underperforms a peer index by 20%, unless Webster determines to adjust consideration. 6 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Transaction Pricing and Comparables Comparable Transactions (1) --------------------------- WBS / FAB Northeast Nationwide --------- --------- ---------- Premium to Market: 7.9% (2) 17.5% 26.1% Price I LTM Reported EPS: 16.4x 19.8x 19.9x Price / 2003E EPS: (3) 18.7x 18.2x 19.8x Price / Book Value: (4) 2.08x 2.30x 2.16x Price / Tangible Book Value: (4) 2.83x 2.45x 2.40x Core Deposit Premium: (5) 22.4% 23.9% 20.4% 1. Thrift acquisitions announced since January 1, 2002 with deal value between $l00 million and $1 billion. Numbers represent average values. Source of information for comparable transactions is SNL Financial. 2. Based on FIRSTFED's closing stock price of $22.70 on October 3, 2003. 3. 2003 calendar year estimate is IBES mean earnings estimate. For comparable transactions, represents current year earnings multiple at the time of transaction announcement. 4. Based on stated book value and intangible assets as of June 30, 2003. 5. Core deposits exclude all CDs greater than $100,000. 7 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] FIRSTFED At-a-Glance FIRSTFED's operations and culture are an excellent strategic fit with Webster - $2.68 billion in assets - $1.38 billion in loans Attractive Commercial - $1.53 billion in deposits (63.5% transaction and Community and savings) Banking Franchise - 24% of FIRSTFED's loans are commercial & industrial - Recently developed trust company and an insurance agency - 26 branches in Bristol, Plymouth and Norfolk counties in Massachusetts and Providence, Kent and Newport counties in Rhode Island Market Position - a FIRSTFED ranks #3 in Bristol County, MA in terms of total deposits - #12 in Boston MSA and #8 in Providence MSA - ROAA: 1.01% - ROAE: 12.86% Solid Profitability - NPAs/Assets: 0.08% and Asset Quality - Reserves/NPLs: 10.2 times - NCOs/Avg. Loans: 0.02% Note: Data as of or for the quarter ended June 30, 2003. 8 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Strategic Rationale - Natural extension of Webster's franchise into adjacent market areas of Massachusetts and Rhode Island FranchiseEnhancing - Creates a powerful regional financial services provider - Consistent with Webster's long-term strategic plan of pursuing in-market and adjacent market acquisitions - Attractive bank-like loan and deposit mix - Like Webster, FIRSTFED is transitioning to a bank-like business mix Similar Strategy - FIRSTFED's market demographics compare favorably with and Markets those of Webster - FIRSTFED's markets are the types of communities in which Webster has had success 9 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Strategic Rationale - 1.4%, or 6 cents, accretion to GAAP EPS in 2005 Attractive Financial - 1.7%, or 7 cents, accretion to cash EPS in 2005 Results - Webster has a track record of exceeding initial projections - FIRSTFED has solid fundamentals and a low-risk balance sheet Low-risk - FIRSTFED is a "clean" institution with similar Transaction business lines - Webster has demonstrated success in executing and integrating comparable transactions 10 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Expanding Webster's Successful Community Banking Franchise into MA and RI [Map of Massachusetts and Rhode Island with surround towns indicating Webster Bank and FIRSTFED franchises] 11 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] FIRSTFED Market Positions RANK DEPOSITS BRANCHES SHARE Bristol, MA 3 $987.7 14 14.6 % Plymouth, MA 14 140.3 4 2.6 Providence, RI 5 130.2 4 1.3 Kent, RI 8 33.4 1 1.5 Norfolk, MA 44 32.7 1 0.2 Newport, RI 6 1.8 1 0.2 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Boston MSA 12 $1,160.6 19 1.0 % Providence MSA 8 163.6 5 1.1 Source: SNL Financial. Data as of June 30, 2002. Excludes institutional deposits. Deposits in millions. 12 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Financial Overview SIGNIFICANT OPPORTUNITIES TO IMPROVE NET INTEREST MARGIN, OPERATING EFFICIENCY AND FEE INCOME GENERATION ($ IN MILLIONS) WEBSTER FIRSTFED ------- -------- BALANCE SHEET ITEMS ------------------------------------ Assets $14,453 $2,681 Net Loans 8,591 1,379 Deposits 8,086 1,529 Equity 1,099 199 Core Deposits/ Total Deposits (1) 67.6 % 63.5 % INCOME STATEMENT ITEMS -------------------------------------- ROAA 1.15 % 1.01 % ROAE 15.0 12.9 Net Interest Margin 3.10 2.60 Efficiency Ratio 58.7 62.2 Fee Income/Revenue (2) 31.2 11.6 FINANCIAL DATA AS OF OR FOR THE QUARTER ENDED JUNE 30, 2003. 1. CORE DEPOSITS EXCLUDE ALL TIME DEPOSITS. 2. FEE INCOME AND REVENUE EXCLUDE SECURITIES GAINS AND GAINS ON SALES OF LOANS AND LOAN SERVICING. 13 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Significant Fee Income Opportunities - The FIRSTFED franchise offers significant fee income growth potential: FIRSTFED WEBSTER Fee Income / Revenue (1) 12% 31% Fee Income / Employee (1) $2,758 $16,709 - Provides significant fee growth opportunities from the addition of Webster's broad product array: - High Performance Checking - Asset based lending - Consumers - Small businesses - Equipment finance - Commercial business lending - Investment products - Small business lending - Wealth Management/Trust - Insurance brokerage - Cash management 1. FEE INCOME AND REVENUE EXCLUDE SECURITIES GAINS AND GAINS ON SALES OF LOANS AND LOAN SERVICING. DATA FOR THE QUARTER ENDED JUNE 30, 2003. 14 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Similar, Diverse Loan Mix AT JUNE 30, 2003 ($ in millions) WEBSTER FIRSTFED COMBINED LOANS % LOANS % LOANS % Commerdal & Industrial $2,010 23.1 $340 24.3% $2,350 23.2% Commercial Real Estate 1,144 13.1 158 11.3 1,302 12.9 Residential Real Estate 3,542 40.7 698 49.9 4,240 41.9 Consumer 2,013 23.1 203 14.5 2,216 21.9 -------------- --------------- --------------- TOTAL LOANS $8,710 100.0% $1,398 100.0% $10,108 100.0% Less: Loan Loss Reserve (119) (19) (139) ------- ------- -------- NET LOANS $8,591 $1,379 $9,970 ------- ------- -------- ------- ------- -------- NOTE: COMBINED NUMBERS DO NOT REFLECT PURCHASE ACCOUNTING ADJUSTMENTS. 15 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Attractive Funding Base At or for the quarter ended June 30, 2003 ($ in millions) WEBSTER FIRSTFED COMBINED --------------- -------------- ---------------- DEPOSITS % DEPOSITS % DEPOSITS % -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Checking and NOW $2,100 26.0% $656 42.9% $2,756 28.7% Savings and MMDA5 3,366 41.6 314 20.6 3,679 38.3 Certificates of Deposit 2,526 31.2 559 36.5 3,085 32.0 Treasury Deposits 94 1.2 - - 94 1.0 ----------------- -------------- ------------------ TOTAL DEPOSITS $8,086 100.0% $1,529 100.0% $9,614 100.0% ----------------- -------------- ------------------ ----------------- -------------- ------------------ NOTE: COMBINED NUMBERS DO NOT REFLECT PURCHASE ACCOUNTING ADJUSTMENTS. 16 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Strong Asset Quality AT OR FOR THE QUARTER ENDED JUNE 30, 2003 WEBSTER FIRSTFED COMBINED ------- -------- -------- Non-Performing Assets/Total Assets 0.39% 0.08% 0.35% Non-Performing Assets/Total Loans 0.65 0.15 0.59 Reserves/Total Loans 1.37 1.39 1.37 Reserves/Non-Performing Loans 228 1,015 256 Net Charge-Offs/Average Loans 0.20 0.02 0.17 NOTE: COMBINED NUMBERS DO NOT REFLECT PURCHASE ACCOUNTING ADJUSTMENTS. 17 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] People's Mortgage Corp. ("PMC") - Retail mortgage originator and wholly-owned subsidiary of FIRSTFED - Conducts business through 9 loan origination centers - 3 in Massachusetts, 1 in Rhode Island, 1 in Connecticut, 4 in Maryland - Originated approximately $3 billion of mortgage loans in the twelve-month period ended June 30, 2003 - Street earnings estimates for FIRSTFED in 2004 reflect analyst expectations that national mortgage origination volume and FIRSTFED mortgage origination volume will decrease significantiy - Webster expects PMC's earnings will account for less than 2% of Webster's pro forma combined earnings in 2004 and beyond, and less than 7% of FIRSTFED's estimated pro forma earnings 18 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Pro Forma Impact - Assumptions - Webster's earnings based on IBES mean 2004 EPS estimate grown at 8% per annum. - FIRSTFED's earnings based on IBES mean 2004 EPS estimate grown at 8% per annum. Earnings have been adjusted to reflect elimination of $1.5 million in annual after-tax CDI amortization expense. - Assumes cost savings equivalent to 25% of FIRSTFED's expense base taking into account 5% annual expense growth. Cost savings phased in 75% in 2004 and 100% thereafter. - Assumes $1.5 billion of balance sheet deleveraging through a combination of investment portfolio reduction and/or loan sales/securitization at a cost of approximately $4.9 million to pre-tax earnings. - Assumes a 4.5% pre-tax opportunity cost of cash. - Core deposit intangible equivalent to 3% of FIRSTFED's core deposits amortized straight-line over 7 years. - Zero revenue enhancements assumed. 19 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] GAAP and Cash EPS Impact PROJECTION FOR CALENDAR YEAR -------------------------------------------- 2004 (1) 2005 ---------------- ---------------- Current GAAP EPS Estimate $3.77 $4.07(2) Pro Forma GAAP EPS 3.81 4.13 GAAP ACCRETION TO WEBSTER ($) $0.04 $0.06 GAAP ACCRETION TO WEBSTER (%) 1.0% 1.4% Stand-Alone Cash EPS Estimate $4.00 $4.31 Pro Forma Cash EPS 4.06 4.38 CASH ACCRETION TO WEBSTER ($) $0.06 $0.07 CASH ACCRETION TO WEBSTER (%) 1.4% 1.7% 1. ASSUMES MERGER CONSUMMATION AT 3/31/2004. INCLUDING ONE-TIME MERGER RELATED COSTS IN 2004 OF $3.1 MILLION AFTER-TAX, TRANSACTION IS DILUTIVE TO GAAP EPS BY $0.03 OR 0.7% AND CASH EPS BY $0.01 OR 0.2%. 2. BASED ON 2004 IBES MEAN EPS ESTIMATE GROWN AT 8%. 20 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Pro Forma Impact - Earnings (in millions) PROJECTIONS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ------------------------------------------- 2004(1) 2005 -------------- ---------------- Webster Earnings $171.0 $184.6 FIRSTFED Earnings 17.8 25.5 Anticipated Cost Savings 9.0 12.6 Net Cash Opportunity Cost (5.3) (6.8) Impact of Balance Sheet Deleveraging (2.3) (3.2) CDI Amortization Expense (2.1) (2.8) Net Accretion of Fair Value Adjustments 1.8 2.4 -------- --------- PRO FORMA NET INCOME $189.9 $212.3 Intangible Amortization Expense 12.7 13.3 -------- --------- PRO FORMA CASH NET INCOME $202.6 $225.6 1. Assumes merger consummation at 3/31/2004. Excludes one-time merger related costs in 2004 of $3.1 million after-tax. 21 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Realistic and Achievable Cost Savings ($ in millions) FIRSTFED Projected for Sources of Cost Savings CY 2005 (1) ----------------------------------------- -------------- Salaries and Benefits $13.7 Professional Fees, Facilities and Other 5.2 ------ TOTAL COST SAVINGS (PRE-TAX) $18.9 TOTAL COST SAVINGS (AFTER-TAX) $12.6 PERCENT OF FIRSTFED 2005 EXPENSE (1) 24.6% IMPLIED EFFICIENCY RATIO FOR FIRSTFED (2) 48.4% 1. Assumes 5% annual expense growth from quarter end June 30, 2003 reported numbers. 2. Based on FIRSTFED 2Q CY2003 annualized non-interest expense of $68.1 million before amortization of intangible assets and 2Q CY2003 annualized net revenue of $106.2 million before provision for loan losses and gain on sale of securities. 22 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Rapid Capital Generation PRO FORMA FOR THE TRANSACTION, CAPITAL LEVELS REMAIN COMFORTABLY ABOVE REGULATORY "WELL CAPITALIZED" REQUIREMENTS AND STRENGTHEN CONSIDERABLY BY THE END OF 2004 Webster Standalone at Pro Forma Transaction at Pro Forma Transaction 6/30/03 (1) 3/31/04 (close) at 12/31/04 [bar graph] [bar graph] [bar graph] Note: Dotted line area represents excess over regulatory "well capitalized" requirements. 1. Adjusted for the issuance of S75 million of trust preferred securities on September 18, 2003 and pending acquisition of North American Bank and Trust Company. 23 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Proven Merger Integration Experience - Webster is strong operationally and a highly experienced acquiror - Webster has successfully integrated over 20 depository and finance company transactions since the early 1990's - Realistic expense saving targets and no revenue enhancements assumed - Earnings estimates for FIRSTFED are conservative - Similar organizations - strong asset quality, similar balance sheet composition and market demographics 24 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Merger Integration Track Record (IN MILLIONS) ASSETS ACQUIRED/ DEPOSITS ACQUIRED BANK/FINANCE ASSETS WBS ASSETS AT DEPOSITS /WBS DEPOSITS YEAR COMPANY ACQUIRED ANNOUNCEMENT ACQUIRED AT ANNOUNCEMENT ---- -------------------- --------- ------------ --------- ---------------- 1991 SuffIeld Bank $301.4 42.9% $264.1 46.3% 1992 First Constitution Bank 1,300.3 47.7 1,222.7 166.9 1993 Bristol Savings Bank 504.3 23.9 478.2 28.7 1994 Shoreline Bank & Trust 51.0 1.9 47.4 2.2 1995 Shelton Bancorp 295.0 10.6 271.4 12.5 1995 Shawmut Branch Purchase 807.0 26.6 850.0 39.4 1996 DS Bancor, Inc. 1,257.4 32.8 1,031.0 33.2 1997 People's Savings Financial 482.4 12.3 358.1 11.6 1997 Sachem Trust Company N.A. 300.0 4.9 NA NA 1997 Eagle Financial Corp. 2,013.4 29.6 1,385.4 32.5 1998 Maritime Bank & Trust 103.7 1.1 91.2 1.6 1998 Village Bancorp, Inc. 234.3 2.6 215.6 3.8 1999 New England Community 786.9 8.9 635.0 11.5 1999 Chase Manhattan Bank branches NA NA 165.0 3.0 1999 FleetBoston branches NA NA 138.0 2.5 1999 MECH Financial, Inc. 1,097.2 12.2 664.7 11.9 2001 Center Capital Corp. 260.0 2.3 NM NM 2002 IBJ Whitehall 500.0 4.1 NM NM 2003 Budget Installment Corp. NA NA NM NM 2003 North American Bank 192.0 1.3 147.9 1.9 2003 FirstFed $2,680.5 18.5% $1,528.5 18.9% SOURCE: SNL FINANCIAL. INCLUDES BANK AND FINANCE COMPANY ACQUISITIONS ONLY. 25 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Summary - Creates a powerful force in southern New England - FIRSTFED possesses strong fundamentals - Great strategic fit that enhances franchise - Consistent with Webster's strategy of pursuing in-market or adjacent-market acquisitions of high quality companies - Solid earnings accretion with achievable cost savings projections - Significant fee income opportunities identified - Balance sheet deleveraging significantly improves funding mix, accelerating transformation to a commercial bank - Webster has a proven track record of integrating acquisitions 26 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Appendix FIRSTFED Market Positions Bristol, MA Rank Institution Branches Deposits Market Share -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 FleetBoston Financal Corp. (MA) 29 $1,179.4 17.37 2 Seacoast Financial Services (MA) 3 FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP 14 1,129.7 16.64 4 Beacon Bankcorp (MA) 9 547.7 8.07 5 Royal Bank of Scotland Group 15 450.5 6.64 6 Sovereign Bancorp Inc. (PA) 11 388.3 5.72 7 Narragansett Financial Corp. (MA) 7 378.2 5.57 8 Slade's Ferry Bancorp (MA) 11 343.9 5.07 9 Fall River Five Cents Svgs Bk (MA) 8 340.7 5.02 10 North Easton Savings Bank (MA) 7 310.3 4.57 Plymouth, MA Rank Institution Branches Deposits Market Share -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 Independent Bank Corp. (MA) 31 $1,176.3 21.42% 2 Royal Bank of Scotland Group 14 79.3 14.45 3 Plymouth Bancorp Inc. (MA) 11 592.4 10.79 4 Abington Bancorp Inc. (MA) 9 463.2 8.43 5 FleetBoston Financial Corp. (MA) 113 339.2 6.18 6 Seacoast Financial Services (MA) 8 258.2 4.70 7 Hingham Instit. for Savings (MA) 4 209.9 3.82 8 Campello Bancorp (MA) 4 183.5 3.34 9 Sovereign Bancorp Inc. (PA) 8 176.8 3.22 10 Bridgewater Savings Bank (MA) 4 169.9 3.09 14 FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP 4 140.30 2.55 Newport, RI Rank Institution Branches Deposits Market Share -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. Bank of Nweport (RI) 7 $475.3 48.80% 2 Royal Bank of Scotland Group 5 189.0 19.40 3 FleetBoston Financial Corp. (MA) 4 111.8 11.48 4 Sovereign Bancorp Inc. (PA) 2 109.3 11.22 5 Newport FSB (RI) 2 86.9 8.92 6 FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP 1 1.8 0.18 Kent, RI Rank Institution Branches Deposits Market Share -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 Royal Bank of Scotland Group 12 $903.5 40.18% 2 Centreville Savings Bank (RI) 4 468.7 20.85 3 FleetBoston Financial Corp. (MA) 5 246.6 10.97 4 Sovereign Bancorp Inc. (PA) 3 243.9 10.85 5 Bancorp Rhode Island Inc. (RI) 4 144.0 6.40 6 Home Loan Financial Corp. (RI) 2 113.3 5.04 7 MetLife Inc. (NY) 1 83.4 3.71 8 FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP 1 33.4 1.49 9 Massachusetts State Carpenters (MA) 1 7.4 0.33 10 Sargent Investors Inc. (RI) 1 4.2 0.19 Norfolk, MA Rank Institution Branches Deposits Market Share -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 FleetBoston Financial Corp. (MA) 35 $3,255.3 23.45% 2 Royal Bank of Scotland Group 30 2,544.5 18.33 3 Sovereign Bancorp Inc. (PA) 17 705.8 5.09 4 Dedham Institution for Savings (MA) 9 704.3 5.07 5 Brookline Bancorp Inc. (MA) 5 632.6 4.56 6 South Shore Savings Bank (MA) 10 581.7 4.19 7 Eastern Bank Corporation (MA) 7 404.7 2.92 8 Bank of Canton (The)(MA) 3 360.5 2.60 9 Benjamin Franklin Bancorp MHC (MA) 6 336.4 2.42 10 Seacoast Financial Serices (MA) 5 323.3 2.33 44 FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP 1 32.7 0.24 Providence, RI Rank Institution Branches Deposits Market Share -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 Royal Bank of Scotland Group 48 $4,793.2 47.63% 2 FleetBoston Financial Corp. (MA) 34 2,847.8 28.30 3 Sovereign Bankcorp Inc. (PA) 21 1,306.4 12.98 4 Bancorp Rhode Island Inc. (RI) 9 557.2 5.54 5 FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP 4 130.2 1.29 6 Sargent Investors Inc. (RI) 1 129.3 1.28 7 Washington Trust Bancorp (RI) 2 121.2 1.20 8 Home Loan Financial Corp. (RI) 1 89.6 0.89 9 Milford FS&LA (MA) 1 42.8 0.43 10 Centreville Savings Bank (RI) 1 14.5 0.14 Source: SNL Financial. Deposit data as of June 30, 2002. Deposits in millions. Excludes institutional deposits. 28 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] FIRSTFED Historical Financial Performance ($ in millions) Fiscal Year Ended March 31, Qtr Ended June 30, -------------------------------- -------------------- Balance Sheet Items 2001 2002 2003 2002 2003 ------------------- ---------- ---------- --------- ------------ -------- Assets $l.67l $2,294 $2,414 $2,408 $2,68l Securities 552 723 718 895 777 Loans, net 977 1,126 1,241 1,131 1,379 MSRs 6 5 5 6 5 Deposits 707 1,317 1,427 1,323 1,529 Borrowings 815 755 712 841 873 Tang. Shareholders' Equity 110 100 139 110 146 Profitability -------------------- Core Income $9.2 $135 $23.0 $4.4 $6.3 Core ROAA 0.78 % 0.70 % 0.95 % 0.78 % 1.01 % Core ROAE 11.8 9.7 13.0 11.8 12.9 NIM 2.66 2.27 262 2.66 2.60 Efficiency Ratio NA 59.5 61.5 68.5 62.2 Fee Income/Operating Revenue 19.4 20.5 13.8 15.0 11.6 Asset Quality --------------------- NCOs / Avg. Loans 0.02 % 0.04 % 0.04 % 0.04 % 0.02 % NPAs/Assets 0.09 0.31 0.14 0.12 0.08 Reserves / Loans 1.34 1.68 1.53 1.67 1.40 NPLs / Loans 0.13 0.32 0.26 0.23 0.14 Reservess/PLs 993.47 519.4 585.0 718.6 NM Capital Adequacy and Other --------------------- Tang. Equity/Tang. Assets 6.61 % 4.45 % 591 % 4.69% 5.57 % Leverage Ratio 6.27 5.72 6.08 5.51 5.66 Total Risk Based Capital Ratio 13.58 10.36 11.02 11.18 10.58 Borrowings/Assets 48.8 32.9 29.5 34.9 32.6 Loans Serviced for Others $l,53l $l,588 $1,412 $l,582 1,292 MSRs/Loans Serviced for Others 0.39 % 0.31 % 0.35 % 0.40 % 0.40 % Source: SNL Financial and Company reports. 29 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] Estimated Deal Costs ($ IN MILLIONS) COST ---- Employee-Related Costs $24.6 Contract Termination Costs 11.8 Transaction Costs 6.4 ------ TOTAL RESTRUCTURING CHARGE (PRE-TAX) $42.8 Taxes (1) (12.2) ------ TOTAL RESTRUCTURING CHARGE (AFTER-TAX) $30.6 ------ ------ 1. Assumes 85% of total restructuring charge is tax deductible. 30 [Webster Logo] [FirstFed Logo] [WEBSTER FINANCIAL FIRSTFED CORPORATION LOGO] FIRSTFED AMERICA BANCORP, INC.[LOGO] We Find a Way A POWERFUL FORCE IN SOUTHERN NEW ENGLAND