Skip to main content

The Comprehensive Guide To Selling A Rental Property On Long Island

The Comprehensive Guide To Selling A Rental Property On Long IslandPhoto from Unsplash

Originally Posted On:


  • Retiring?
  • Bad Tenants
  • Difficulty Collecting Rent?

Are you thinking about selling your rental property? If so, then it’s important to be aware of some of the key challenges and issues that you can encounter. This is particularly important if you are selling a property on Long Island as there are challenges that are unique to this area. You will also need to consider whether you are prepared to sell your property with tenants in situ. Despite some key differences, the good news is that selling a rental property is quite similar to a conventional property sale. However, before we explore this in more detail and what you need to know when selling property like this, it’s important to understand some general details about the Long Island rental property market.

Understanding The Long Island Rental Property Market

The first step before you can sell your rental property on Long Island is to understand the property’s market. There are a few key details to be aware of here. First, it’s important to be aware that the 4.3% rental vacancy rate means that there are less available rental homes compared to other popular areas around New York. For instance, areas such as New Jersey and Hudson Valley have more than twice this number available. This is good news as it means there’s a lot of demand from prospective buyers and it’s a wide open rental market.

However, it also means that you need to make sure that you are appealing to the new owner. Part of this is ensuring that your home is located in the right area. While rental homes make up 21% of the homes on Long Island, these are mainly located in communities.

When pricing your rental property whether it is an inherited property or a property investment, you need to think about key factors. This includes the location, whether the property requires any maintenance work and how appealing it is to buyers.

The Legal Aspects Of Selling Your Rental Property

There are some local laws and legal elements of selling a rental property that you need to be aware of too. For instance, you need to consider the legal rights of the current tenants. Can you sell a new rental property if tenants still live there and the current lease hasn’t expired. The good news is that you can sell with tenants living in your property. However, you will need to determine the rental agreement with your tenants before moving forward with this process.

Another legal impact to consider is capital gains tax implications. When you sell your rental property, regardless of your lease agreement, you will always incur tax charges. These are going to be far more than you would need to pay if you were planning on selling a different property to potential buyers like your family home. One of the best ways to manage this is by leveraging section 1031 of the Tax-Code. This is also referred to as the “life-kind” exchange. It can help you defer capital gains taxes. The capital gains tax is one of the more challenging legal issues you can encounter.

Preparing Your Rental Property For Sale

Next, let’s explore how to prepare your rental property for sale. There are lots of steps that you can take when selling your rental property which will lead to a smooth sale. First, you should think about making any key repairs or improvements. If the property has fallen into a state of disrepair, then you are always going to struggle to attract investors who are interested in buying properties like yours. However, you do need to be careful about how much you spend on your Long Island House. You don’t want to end up putting more in than you will get back.

Remember, you can sell the house as is or you can make some improvements. The key variable relating to the selling process impacted by this decision is how much you will be able to sell your home for. We’ll explore this further down.

More buyers are looking for the fastest sale possible so it’s important that you take the necessary steps to make this a reality.


Navigating Tenant Occupied Property Lease

Arguably one of the biggest challenges will be attempting a home sale if you are still managing an occupied lease. A good tenant will help ensure that your property sale does go smoothly. However, they can make things a tad difficult. For instance, if they are on a month to month lease then they have a legal right to stay in the property as long as they continue to pay rent. A month-to-month lease protects tenants for the full lease term.

One of the easiest ways to dodge legal issues and avoid paying fines is to simply let the lease expire. When you begin the eviction process, you should also notify them of the sale of your rental home or property. This will be ideal if you are keen to maintain the relationship with your tenant and ensure that you get your security deposit back.

On the other hand, if you need a fast sale and are hoping to attract legitimate homebuyers in a key timeframe while managing moving costs, you’ll need to explore other options. First, you could sell the property to the tenant who has your current lease. This is a good will gesture but it does depend if your tenants are in financial distress and whether they will be able to pay as much as a new landlord in New York. Do be aware when you sell a rental property like this, they could also request repairs. This can lead to significantly higher costs than other financial issues like closing costs or even capital gains.

You could also pay your tenant to leave if they do have a month-to-month contract. However, before you take this step for a month-to-month tenant, you should always check whether there’s an early termination clause which is part of their original rental agreement.

Pricing Your Rental Property For The Long Island Market

Once you have navigated the challenges relating to an existing tenant and figured out when your lease expires, you need to consider other factors that will impact you when selling property and determine whether or not you are successful. For instance, you’ll need to consider the price that is going to attract potential buyers. Remember, all real estate investors will be operating on a set budget and won’t pay over the market value for a new property.

That’s why if you are selling a new property with tenants or without tenants you’ll need to make sure that you match the market value. The first step will be to understand the local housing market. The housing market in New York is constantly changing and this will impact the real value of your home for a potential property owner. One of the best ways to determine the value of your property is to using a real estate agent. Real estate agents will help you ascertain the market price. A listing agent can also help you gain attention from key homebuyers in New York.

The value and market price of investment properties are impacted by various factors including property appreciation. It’s possible that your home has increased in value over the years, improving its position in the real estate market.

<img class=”attachment-large size-large wp-image-2572 entered exited” src=”data:;base64,” alt=”woman deciding on a sales price for her old rental property” width=”700″ height=”500″ data-lazy-srcset=” 700w,×214.png 300w” data-lazy-sizes=”(max-width: 700px) 100vw, 700px” data-lazy-src=”” />

Market Strategies For Rental Properties

Another key element to consider is the market strategies for selling rental properties. Again, you need to make sure that you are appealing to key real estate investors. You can either aim to grab a fast sale or wait until the local property market in New York reaches it’s highest point. As mentioned, you can also sell directly to your current tenant if they are in the position to complete an investment like this.

The Role Of Cash House Buyers In Rental Properties

Arguably, one of the easiest ways to avoid issues when selling your property is to explore selling to a real estate New York cash buyer. A big benefit here is that you won’t have to worry about seller financing issues slowing down or even preventing the sale of the property. A typical real estate investor may be looking at properties before they are fully prepared to close the sale. Cash buyers will move forward with the real estate transaction as quickly as possible.

If they find a property with massive levels of potential in New York, then they could also help you remove a tenant from their current lease agreement with the right financial incentive. This useful if you do have property with tenants still living there or tenants who are occupying a fixed term lease.

A more traditional real estate investor may be happy to wait for the current tenancy agreement to end before they become a new owner.

Cash buyers like We Buy Long Island Homes Fast can provide support by providing the best deal for a rental property with a fast sale guaranteed.

Of course, there are also disadvantages of selling to a cash buyer. For instance, it’s possible that a typical real estate investor will end up paying slightly less for your home although it will sell much faster.

Understanding Taxes and Financial Implications

There are tax and financial implications of selling a home regardless of whether you have a property with tenants or not. We have already discussed capital gains. If you have an inherited property, then you might be able to take advantage of Section 1301 of the tax code when selling property. Alternatively, you offset the cost through tax loss harvesting.

Do be aware that when you sell a rental, all depreciation deduction claims made are recaptured. This works similar to typical IRAs where real estate investors can deduct contributions on New York tax returns.

The Process of Closing The Sale

Once you have navigated selling a property with tenants, you’ll then need to navigate the closing process. This includes closing costs, paperwork and finalizing the sale. This is a complex process and it is vital that you have a legal advisor on your side to navigate some of the key aspects. Once the sale is finalized, you can hand over the keys and spend your profits.

Common Mistakes To Avoid When Selling Rental Property

When selling a rental property, it is important to avoid some of the more common landlord mistakes and pitfalls. Arguably, the biggest mistake is selling without fully understanding your lease agreement. If you are not aware of your rights in terms of your lease agreements including when your lease expires, then it could lead to a disaster. Attempting a sale could tie your home up in red tape for years. Remember, you can only sell when your tenant’s lease ends unless you are prepared to buy them out before the end of their fixed-term lease. A fixed team lease will typically be anything from twelve months to two years. Of course, you could have rights to evict a tenant, particularly if they have fallen behind with rent payments.

Another mistake could be selling your property in New York for more than it is worth. Most real estate investors will buy rental property for more than you might imagine. However, a lot of buyers are too eager for a fast sale which leads to lost profits. Regardless of whether you are worried about building property taxes or missing a potential cash sale, you should always consult with a real estate expert to ensure that you get the best possible price for your property in New York.



We hope this helps you understand everything that you need to be aware of when selling rental houses on Long Island, New York. Remember, before you sell, you need to understand the legal and financial implications. For instance, if it is a property that has been inherited then you could have obligations such as mortgage payments. You will also need to consider whether you are trying to sell rental property with tenants in place.

Don’t forget, that you can still sell houses with tenants, but you will need to navigate the lease terms. If you have tenants with month-to-month lease terms, then you can end their lease and provide notice that you are preparing for sale. You may also continue collecting rental payments until the tenancy ends.

Finally, regardless of whether you sell property with tenants or an empty home, you could benefit from a cash purchase. This will help you avoid some of the roadblocks and take advantage of a smooth process when closing the sale.

Data & News supplied by
Stock quotes supplied by Barchart
Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes.
By accessing this page, you agree to the following
Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.